Bigthink - Idea Comments Feed

Comment on: An Essay on Alrtuism

Bigthink — Sun, 03 Feb 2008 21:24:35 +0100

I like the way you expressed your ideas. With clarity and to the point. You present in such a way that my only comment would be to 'flesh out' or 'add' to. Something that I believe is impossible on an internet site. therefore I might suggest you 'don't cast your pearls before swine'. I was especially pleased that you supported your argument by quoting authority and not some shallow pop lyric. Careful with those 'pearls' mi amigo. -Pedro-

Comment on: An Essay on Alrtuism

Bigthink — Sat, 02 Feb 2008 23:11:54 +0100

What religious person doesn't want to get into heaven? That's what most people seem to like about it, the idea that your death won't be the end of your existence.

As far as sex. No one said giving to your partners desires was altruistic. I said devoting yourself entirely to that person was not altruistic.

As far as not "bashing" Joan of Arc, I already touched on religion and didn't want to go over that again. As far as fiction, I think it's just all too true. Shakespeare wrote "The purpose of art is to hold a mirror up to nature herself," so by writing out what Darnay was thinking, Dickens illuminated the human condition which he was the master of doing.

As far as your definition of altruism, I clearly disagree. That is very much materialistic altruism and not just altruism.

Comment on: An Essay on Alrtuism

Bigthink — Thu, 17 Jan 2008 20:45:57 +0100

I would have to ask you to cite your source that says that St. Katherine's only purpose was to get into heaven? No where in that essay did you state that as your opinion.

As far as sex goes. Who ever said that giving in to your partners desires was being altruistic?

Your example of martyrdom is one of fiction. Why don't you bash Joan Of Arc instead. Then we could hear more about your opinions instead of fact.

As far a the essay goes, I don't think you proved anything. As for your ideas about altruism. When you feel good about giving, that is a natural effect. It is a personal benefit surely, but it is not a tangible benefit. Tangible benefits are what I believe the definition of the word refers too.

Comment on: An Essay on Alrtuism

Bigthink — Thu, 17 Jan 2008 09:41:41 +0100

I can't think of much more to say other than I agree. You can say in essence that even if we strive to be selfless, any selfless act we perform is self-serving as it helps us achieve the goal of being selfless.