http://www.bigthink.com/adobe/Logo_250X250.jpg http://www.bigthink.com/adobe/Background_1024X576.jpg http://www.bigthink.com/adobe/Banner_686X60.jpg http://www.bigthink.com/adobe/Half-Banner_234X60.jpg http://www.bigthink.com/adobe/Logo_250X250 http://www.bigthink.com/adobe/Logo-Watermark_250X250.jpg http://www.bigthink.com/adobe/Background_1024X576.jpg http://www.bigthink.com/adobe/Half-Banner-ALT_234X60.jpg Bigthink - User Ideas Feed Bigthink http://www.bigthink.com/feed/rss/user/9481 Wed, 09 Jul 2008 12:15:30 +0100 FeedCreator 1.7.2 When does a work of Theatre Art Fail? http://www.bigthink.com/arts-culture/theater-film/7441 At the University of New Hampshire the arts department (mainly the Theatre and Dance but thte others have chipped in too) have had an ongoing discussion this year about the relationship between art and democracy.  A Professor of mine brought up the point that whenever the University puts on a show that only entertains and does not challenge the veiwer to think, the University fails.

 

I have taken it one step further to say that any play that only entertains, fails.  If somthing is meant only to keep you occupied for the amount of time it is on and doesn't challenege you to think, it was a waste of time you can't have back.

 

What do you people think? 

]]>
Bigthink Mon, 18 Feb 2008 20:24:09 +0100 http://www.bigthink.com/arts-culture/theater-film/7441
What of Angels in America? http://www.bigthink.com/arts-culture/theater-film/6774 Bigthink Sat, 02 Feb 2008 23:04:43 +0100 http://www.bigthink.com/arts-culture/theater-film/6774 If you are a religious person, are you mad about Flying Spaghetti Monsterism? http://www.bigthink.com/faith-beliefs/4831 Bigthink Thu, 17 Jan 2008 21:20:33 +0100 http://www.bigthink.com/faith-beliefs/4831 An Essay on Alrtuism http://www.bigthink.com/philanthropy/4529 I wrote this for my freshamn composition class.  I'm curious what people think.

 

Altruism is described as selfless giving on the part of an individual to benefit others but not itself.  An altruistic person would be able to do something that would not bring advantage or pleasure to themselves in any way, solely in the interest of bringing advantage or pleasure to others.  While the romantic in us would like to believe that selfless giving is possible, I believe that the idea of altruism is purely that, an idea.  No one in this world gives without getting something in return, whether it is compensation in the future, the pleasure of pleasing another, or a good name for their generosity.  Everyone gives in hoping to receive, despite what we as an optimistic society want to believe.  Altruism is simply an idea, not a working way of life.

                There are many different arenas in which the idea of altruism can try to hold it’s ground, including religion, sex, and martyrdom.  In each one of these categories altruism is believed to be a working philosophy and is held up as an ideal to aspire to.  But do any of them really stand up to scrutiny based upon research, I think not.  In each one of these areas, anything that could be on the surface mistaken for altruism can be uncovered to be motivated by more selfish means.  Under it all, it comes back to the person performing that action.

                In the field of religion let’s use Saint Katherine Drexel as an example.  St. Katherine was born to a very wealthy family in Philadelphia in 1858.  Her father was an extremely wealthy investment banker and she had all she would have ever needed in her life.  However, at the age of 30 she renounced all the luxuries that she had grown up with in favor of becoming a Nun and taking a vow of poverty.  She used her money, which was an estimated $20 Million in inheritance from her father, to educate and help the poor.  Not long after she started a missionary order, The Sisters of the Blessed Sacrament, with the encouragement of the current Pope, to help underprivileged African and Native Americans.  St. Katherine’s order operated 40 grade schools, 12 high schools, Xavier University, and three houses of social service at the time of her death; she was canonized as a Saint in 2000. (MSN Encarta)

                St. Katherine would seem like an excellent candidate for altruism, she gave up all of her worldly possessions to help people in need and actually helped a lot of underprivileged children.  The problem with that is she gave them up for her religion.  In the Bible it says "It is easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle than for a rich man to enter the kingdom of God" (Matthew 19:24).  This shows that she gave up the money, the power, and the lifestyle; all in the hope of helping her soul get to heaven.  The act, as generous as it was, was not entirely selfless as she assuredly thought she would be rewarded in heaven for helping her fellow man.  It’s not as though what she did wasn’t for good reasons and that it didn’t accomplish good things, but in the subconscious of her mind she knew she was helping herself get into the Kingdom that she believed in so fervently.

                Another aspect of human life that is deeply ingrained in the collective culture of our species is our attraction to other people in a romantic and sexual nature.  It’s not uncommon for people to adopt a very humble nature when dealing with their significant other.  People often will deny themselves things that they love or enjoy in hopes of making the other person happy.  In a sexual connotation it is not uncommon for one partner to ignore their own desires in hoping to satisfy the other person’s needs and desires.

                This would seem a very altruistic attribute: a person totally ignoring their wants and needs in the most intimate of settings in hopes of making their partner happy.  On the surface this seems to be a solid argument for altruism, albeit a bit animal.  The problem is just that though: animal.  Scientist have long said that what really attracts people to their partners is scents excreted through the skin that alert a person to the presence of someone whose genes are a good match with their own.(Rhoads)  Hence the whole purpose of romance is reproduction and the passing of one’s own genetic legacy.  As for the “selflessness” during the act itself, that too is entirely selfish.  Numerous studies have shown that people often derive more pleasure from pleasing others than from being pleased themselves. (Goldman)  So in a roundabout way, making it all about the other person really is making it all about themselves.

                And lastly is what many deem to be “the ultimate sacrifice”, martyrdom.  When one person lays down their life for anther person or for a cause it is often looked upon as the most selfless act one can commit.  It makes sense that this could be considered altruism in practice since the person will no longer be around to reap whatever rewards they will receive from their actions, so what benefit could it possible be to them?  Well that depends on what they died for.

                In this age of religious radicalism and violence we have heard all too often about how Muslim extremists believe that if they die for Islam they will be rewarded in heaven with gratuitous amounts of virgins to wait on their every call.  This shows very clearly that although these men are dieing for something they truly believe in, it is under no circumstances selfless.

                However that is just an extreme case of martyrdom.  Not everyone who dies for something or someone is a religious extremist and believes they will be rewarded in the next life for their sacrifice, so what about just ordinary people?  A good example would be the all too human portrait of martyrdom that Charles Dickens paints at the very end of his classic novel A Tale of Two Cities.  At the very end Sydney Carton takes the place of his beloved Lucie’s husband, Charles Darnay, at the guillotine so that he may live on with her.  This would seem to be a very generous and selfless move; he is dying for the husband of the woman he desperately loves.  However, as he is being lead to the monstrous chopping blade that has claimed so many people throughout history and the novel; he begins to dream of what people will say of him when he is gone.

                He begins to dream of how Lucie and Darnay will tell their children of the honorable Sydney Carton, who laid down his life to save their father.  He envisions himself almost deified in their eyes for his “selfless” sacrifice.  Although the closing line of the novel is one of the more beautiful passages in English literature, it is also entirely selfish.  He says “It is a far, far better thing that I do, than I have ever done before; it is a far, far better rest that I go to than I have ever known.” (Dickens, 372)  He, in a way, gives own eulogy and tells the world, or at least himself, that by doing this he is at peace with himself and all that he has done in his life. Noble? Yes.  Selfless? No.

                In no way do I mean to discredit what any of these people have done for themselves, other, people, or the world.  All of them that have done good things are better people for it. St. Katherine in her giving, ordinary people in their passion, and Carton in his sacrifice, all have left a positive mark on the world and themselves.  I do not mean to detract from the things they have done nor out words in their mouths or thoughts in their mind.  All I have said in this piece is that total and complete selflessness, altruism, is nothing more than a beautiful idea.  A goal for all of us to shoot for, but something none of us can ever reach.  But that doesn’t mean we should stop doing things for the betterment of others, we should just know that somewhere in our action we are helping ourselves as well.

 

]]>
Bigthink Thu, 17 Jan 2008 05:08:40 +0100 http://www.bigthink.com/philanthropy/4529
A letter I wrote to friends over vacation:A rant about sex, drugs, religon,etc http://www.bigthink.com/wisdom/4505 This was a sort of open letter I wrote to my friends during this recent school vacation that is mercifully drawing to an end.  One could say this is a rant, and they'd be right.  But I think this kind of touches on some important things for people my age and as we are "the future" as cliche as it sounds, it is important for the world.  Let me know what you think I'm incredibly curious.

 

The Effects of Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas.

 

All throughout this vacation I have had absolutely nothing to do.  The amount of time that I have had had on my hands is simply staggering and the need to fill it with something worth while has become somewhat of an addiction.  I have been trying to pass said time with gratuitous amounts of reading, writing, and reflecting on my life up to this point in time.  Until as of late, I had no means, or reason for that matter, to connect them all.

 

Then came the bats.

 

This a reference to the masterpiece work of Dr. Hunter S. Thompson, Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas.  The all too true tale of the "savage journey into the heart of the American Dream" has brought together so much of what my life has been and so much of what I've been trying to understand in one simple word: excess.

 

As many of you know I am a staunch straight-edge.  I have never touched any form of drug and have never imbibed a single drop of alcohol, and thought myself better than other people for it.  Throughout high school I laughed at all the people who said they "got hammered" the night before and came to school with a headache but had never been in the vicinity of such people until college.  When that time came and I actually saw people getting red-faced and stupid I thought them swine, base, and all together a lower form of intelligence because of their need to "relax".  Odds are if I've ever been with you while you were drinking I thought this of you.  My mind wanders to one particular evening where I witnessed a game of strip black-jack and was infuriated and disgusted at the bestial nature of the people around me.  And don't even get me started on the mass amounts of people who have asked me if I wanted to light up with them or simply told me stories of such times.  Of course I smile and put on a happy face, but inside I have always been livid with disappointment.

 

But now, something has changed.  As I look back on those times in comparison to the mescaline, LSD, cocaine, ether, amyl, weed, alcohol, and god only knows what else fueled madness of Raoul Duke and Dr. Gonzo as they tore through Sin City taking its name to new heights, you people were nothing.  Looking back on those times I was livid now with the bats looming in my memory, I was flying off the handles for nothing more than mere child's play. 

 

Don't expect me to change my ways due to this new found revelation of everyone I used to look down one’s inadequacy, however.  The way I see it now is kind of an all or nothing deal.  Either you stay clean because you know you can't play with the big boys or as Thompson would have said "Buy the ticket; Take the ride."  And how many of you who have taken part in these so-called "vices" of yours can really live up to that.  So I will still be mocking you and your petty addictions, not because I think I'm better than you, not any more, but because you can't handle the big roller coaster and thus are on the merry-go-round.

 

But the revelations haven't stopped there!  This new wisdom was sent careening into other areas of reflection through the same vein that sent it into excess: college.

 

Since I have been at the University of New Hampshire I have had to deal with drugs (which I have already expounded upon), religion, conformity, politics, and sex more than ever in my life, which isn't all together surprising.

 

Religion had already been bugging me before I stepped onto campus.  I found myself not struggling not over whether or not I believe in the Catholic Church, which I am forced into visiting every once and a while, that faith died long ago and was buried with a friend of mine.  More recently I have been struggling with the question of whether or not there is even such a thing as a "God".  And I can tell you I have very recently come to my conclusion.

 

No.

 

There isn't.

 

And it wasn't even the normal thought processes that I frequent that lead me to this conclusion.  It wasn't the whole "it's an opiate that represses individual thinking" or the "man created a God in order to not feel alone in the world” or even the” I can't believe in something where the 'Devil's' sin was thinking for himself” I wasn't any of those that brought me to this conclusion.  It was the death of a man, and the impending death of another.  Mr.  William Gibson was the music teacher at Kingswood Regional High school for a good amount of years and has had legions of adoring students.  He also had two sons, on e who is a friend on mine, and another who is a friend to my sister.  He recently died of cancer, and left them all behind.  Would a God do that?  And even now a man by the name of George Hamm is lying in a hospital bed about to die of a cancer the doctors told him was long gone.  He had received a "clean bill of health" as he put it.  Now he is about to die.  He was the priest of the church I mentioned earlier.  Apparently it's not enough for a good and kind God to take a father of two sons’ but he also had to take one of the men who have devoted his life to Him.

 

There is no God, only death and the fear of it.

 

And religion is the ultimate conformity, which I have a terrible fear of.  Often times I have refrained from taking part in some activity or something along those lines just for the simple fact that I didn't want to play along.  My friend Amy once told me of the Rocky Horror Show that travels around and how people dress up in all manner of drag and lingerie for the simple need to not be out of place while they scream, in unison, various abuses at the actors who are putting on the show.  She then said one day she'd like to have me go along.  This scarred the shit out of me.  Not that I would be dressed up in girl's clothing but that I would be forced to dress up in girl's clothing is what scarred me.  And recently my girlfriend told me that newcomers to the show must wear a lipstick "V" on their foreheads to signify that they are "virgins".  This also scarred me because of the level of conformity involved.

 

And conformity is rampant in the air this year as the Presidential race slowly and dully sloths it's way across the country and people from all walks of life give up their valuable time on this earth to support some self-serving megalomaniac who doesn't even know they exist.  At UNH the mail room has been clogged with these sheep asking if you have the time to support their candidate and want to join the cause.  I got roped in by one of the Obama people for exactly 3 minutes (I timed it) and the bullshit propaganda pilled up so fast I needed wings to stay above it.  Adam once asked me if it was a bad thing that "Sheep" by Pink Floyd started playing in his head every time he saw them.  I replied, "No, it's appropriate."  I voted for Obama, but not under any circumstances do I "support" him.

 

Another thing that actually angered me about the Rocky Horror Show is how it portrays sex as a sideshow event to be looked at with mirth and whimsy.  Then I stopped and thought for a moment.  That's just a reflection on how society looks at sex.  Sex is used to sell things, get your attention, piss you off, get you on its side, etc.  Essentially sex is used to get things from you today.  It's no longer about a connection between two people, and it long ago ceased being about making babies.  Sex is now a means to an ends and that saddens me greatly because I was once the token virgin of the group who was told he had no right to speak on numerous occasions just because he hadn't "done the deed".  Now here I am no longer a virgin and have decided that the grass isn't as green as people said it was.  And as I look back through the embers of that bridge I left burning behind me, I see the grass isn't much greener over there either.  So in short, who really gives a shit?

 

So there you have it.  As you were all out working, carousing with your friends, going to school, or god only knows what else this vacation, this is what I have been doing: reflecting.  Trent Reznor once asked "When you look at your reflection, is it all you want it to be?"  I can say a true and firm no.  I never wanted to become this cynical person who sees the world as nothing but a pile of lies and mindless follow the leader.  To say I'm not happy though, would be a lie.  I am.  Because as someone very astutely pointed out to me in not an ill meaning way, I am a hypocrite.  I damn this world and all of its ways, only to live the life I have just detested.

 

And I like it.

 

"We can't stop here!  This is Bat Country!"-Dr. Hunter S. Thompson

]]>
Bigthink Thu, 17 Jan 2008 04:36:25 +0100 http://www.bigthink.com/wisdom/4505