Does Tipper Gore Know About This One?

784px-duel_pistolet

Here's a curious study, which reports that "a multivariate logistic regression analysis finds that opera fans are 2.37 times more accepting of suicide because of dishonor than nonfans." The authors think this is because suicide in the name of honor is a theme of many opera plots. They call it the "Madame Butterfly" effect.

You have to wonder how they defined ``fan.'' And how they interpreted those opera plots. For instance, does Tosca leap off the balcony for honor? Or is it because she's about to be booked for murder?

Then too there's the perennial issue of cause and effect. If there's something to this result, we can't say if it means histrionic people are attracted to opera or if, instead, listening to opera makes a person more accepting of midnight duels, poison-quaffing and other forms of honor-defending self-expression.

Still, for anyone whose parents or partners think their gangsta rap/heavy metal/Goth music is anti-life, this one's for you.

Tip of the hat to the guys at Mind Hacks for finding this one.

Tags: emotional contagion, music, opera, suicide

blog comments powered by Disqus

About Mind Matters

284 Posts since 1970

In markets, medicine, justice, politics, psychology, and economics, "Rational Man" is dead. As the science of human behavior enters the post-rational era, we no longer think of ourselves as cool calculators in pursuit of our objective self-interest. Mind Matters is about this change and its effects on how we live. It's about the reasons people perceive, feel, think, and act as they do, and the gaps between what we think we're doing and what research says we're doing. Most importantly, it's about how this sea change affects the institutions we live by: courts, hospitals, governments, stock markets and other entities that still run on the presumption that people act rationally.

Links

Recent Posts